Allstate Medicare Supplement: The 2025 Market Exit and What It Means for Members

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 19, 2026

Allstate Medicare Supplement plans are being phased out: in May 2025, Allstate Health Solutions announced it would leave the Medicare Supplement market state by state, while keeping existing policies in force. If you already own an Allstate Medigap policy, it stays guaranteed renewable as long as you pay the premium, but new shoppers should expect to buy from a different insurer.

2027 by the Numbers

May 2025

month Allstate Health Solutions announced its Medicare Supplement exit (agent notices)

~44,000

Allstate Medigap members affected, per agency reports

$1.25B

price of Allstate’s group health unit sale to Nationwide, closed in 2025 (Allstate)

For a few years, Allstate was one of the bigger brand names in the Medigap aisle. That came through its 2021 purchase of National General, whose health insurance unit had been selling Medicare Supplement plans for years. National General’s health brand was later renamed Allstate Health Solutions.

Then Allstate changed course. It sold off pieces of its health and benefits business and, in 2025, announced it would stop selling Medicare Supplement coverage. This page explains what happened, which companies stand behind existing policies, and what current members should weigh. For background on plan letters, see our list of Medicare Supplement plans.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Allstate announced in May 2025 that it is leaving the Medigap market

✔

Existing policies continue as long as premiums are paid

✔

Policies were issued by Allstate subsidiaries, not by Allstate’s auto company

✔

Members can stay put or shop elsewhere, usually with health questions

Compare plans and enroll online

Timeline: From National General to an Exit Notice

When What happened
January 2021 Allstate completes its purchase of National General Holdings, including its health insurance business
2021 onward National General’s health products, including Medigap, are sold under the Allstate Health Solutions name
Mid-2025 Allstate closes the sale of its group health business to Nationwide for about $1.25 billion
May 2025 Allstate Health Solutions tells agents it will file notices to exit the Medicare Supplement market and moves new sales to paper applications only
After each state’s notice period New Medigap applications stop in that state; existing policies remain in force

Sources: Allstate deal announcements and agent notices reported by Medicare marketing agencies. State-by-state end dates varied with each state’s required notice period.

The Medigap exit fits a wider pattern. Allstate also sold its employer voluntary benefits unit in a separate deal and has said it wants to focus on its core property and casualty business. Individual health products that were not part of those sales were described as either staying with Allstate or being combined elsewhere.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Who Actually Issues an Allstate Medigap Policy

Allstate’s Medicare Supplement plans were not issued by the same company that writes your car insurance. Industry sources list American Heritage Life Insurance Company and National Health Insurance Company as the underwriters behind Allstate Health Solutions Medigap policies. The exact company depends on your state and when you bought.

Allstate Corp.

Parent company

American Heritage Life

One issuing insurer

National Health Ins. Co.

Another issuing insurer

Look at your contract: Your policy schedule names the legal insurer that owes your claims. Use that exact name when you check its AM Best financial strength rating or your state’s complaint records, since ratings are assigned company by company.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Plans and Discounts Allstate Offered

Before the exit, marketing agencies listed Allstate Health Solutions Medigap options as Plans A, F, high-deductible F, G and N, with availability varying by state. Plan F and high-deductible F were only for people eligible for Medicare before 2020. Because Medigap benefits are standardized, an Allstate Plan G pays exactly what any other company’s Plan G pays.

Plan Main costs you still pay Notes
Plan A Part A deductible ($1,736 in 2026), Part B deductible, skilled nursing coinsurance Lowest benefit level
Plan F Nothing for Medicare-approved care Only for those eligible before 2020
High-deductible F Costs up to the yearly deductible ($3,050 in 2027) Only for those eligible before 2020
Plan G Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) Most popular choice for new enrollees
Plan N Part B deductible, some office and ER copays, excess charges Lower premium, more cost sharing

Discounts agencies reported

✔

A roommate or household discount of about 7%, where allowed

✔

A dual-applicant discount of about 10% when two people applied together

✔

Discount rules and amounts varied by state, and existing members keep whatever their policy terms say

What the Exit Means If You Already Have a Policy

Allstate stated that its withdrawal does not affect existing policyholders and that their coverage and service would continue uninterrupted. Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable by law, so the company cannot cancel you because it stopped selling.

What does not change

✔

Your plan letter and benefits

✔

Claims paid through Medicare crossover

✔

No cancellation while premiums are paid

What may change over time

✔

No new members join your pool

✔

An aging pool can mean larger rate increases

✔

Fewer in-house options if you want a different plan

About guaranteed issue: Federal guaranteed issue rights generally apply when your policy actually ends, such as an insurer going bankrupt. A company that simply stops selling new policies while keeping yours in force usually does not trigger that right by itself. Some states add their own protections, so check with your state insurance department.

Should You Stay or Shop Around?

There is no single right answer. If you are happy with your premium and your health has changed, staying may be the safer path because a new insurer could decline you. If you are healthy and your premium has started to climb, comparing now while you can still pass underwriting is reasonable.

1

Check your last two rate notices Note how much the premium rose and when.

2

Get quotes for the same plan letter Compare Plan G to Plan G so the only difference is price and the company.

3

Review your state’s switching rules A few states have birthday rules or yearly windows that let you change without health questions.

4

Keep your policy until the new one starts Cancel only after the replacement is approved and active.

Our page on changing Medicare Supplement plans without underwriting explains when health questions can be skipped.

Compare plans and enroll online

If You Were Planning to Buy Allstate

New shoppers who liked the Allstate name are better served focusing on the plan letter first and the company second. Many still recognize Allstate for dental and vision products; see our Allstate dental and vision insurance page for that line, which is separate from Medigap.

What to look for in a replacement company

✔

Actively selling Medigap in your state, with no announced exit

✔

Financial strength rating of A- or better from AM Best on the issuing company

✔

Moderate rate increase history for your plan letter

✔

A household discount if you live with another adult who has coverage

Where Allstate Fits Among Big Medigap Brands Now

With Allstate stepping back, Medigap sales are concentrated among insurers that have stayed committed to the product line. You can see how the largest players compare on our largest Medicare Supplement companies page.

Watch Part B costs too: Whatever company you choose, the 2026 Part B premium is $202.90 and the deductible is $283, rising to $209.40 and $292 for 2027 under the figures CMS announced on November 17, 2026.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Allstate no longer markets Medicare Supplement plans after announcing its exit in 2025, but existing policies continue under the same benefits as long as premiums are paid. Current members should watch their rate notices and compare while they are healthy, and new shoppers should buy the plan letter they want from a company that is still actively selling.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Does Allstate still sell Medicare Supplement plans?

No new sales are being marketed. Allstate Health Solutions announced in May 2025 that it would exit the Medicare Supplement market, with timing set by each state’s notice requirements.

➤ Will Allstate cancel my Medigap policy?

No. Allstate said existing policyholders keep their coverage, and Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable as long as you pay your premium.

➤ Is Allstate Health Solutions the same as National General?

Yes. Allstate bought National General in 2021, and its health insurance products were later sold under the Allstate Health Solutions name.

➤ Which company is on my Allstate Medigap contract?

Industry sources list American Heritage Life Insurance Company and National Health Insurance Company as the issuing insurers. Your policy schedule shows which one applies to you.

➤ Do I get guaranteed issue because Allstate left the market?

Usually not under federal rules, because your policy is not ending. Some states may offer extra rights, so ask your state insurance department or SHIP counselor.

➤ Will my Allstate premium go up faster now?

It could. With no new members joining, the group ages over time, which often leads to higher increases, though no specific future rate has been announced.

➤ Did Nationwide buy Allstate’s Medicare Supplement business?

Nationwide bought Allstate’s group health business in 2025. Reports on that deal did not include the Medicare Supplement line, which Allstate instead chose to exit.

➤ Can I switch from Allstate Plan G to another company’s Plan G?

Yes, if the new insurer accepts you. In most states that means answering health questions unless you have a guaranteed issue right or a state switching window.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company