Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 31, 2026
The worst Medicare Advantage plans are the ones with low CMS star ratings (especially contracts flagged with the low performer icon for scoring under 3 stars three years in a row), a network that leaves out your doctors, and drug or prior authorization rules that block the care you use. No single company is the worst everywhere, because every plan is rated by contract and sold county by county, so you have to check the exact plan in your ZIP code.
2027 by the Numbers
5,481
individual Medicare Advantage plans for 2027 (our analysis of CMS 2027 plan data)
32
contracts rated 2.5 stars or lower in the 2027 Star Ratings, up from 23 (CMS data via Becker’s)
7.7%
of 2024 prior authorization requests fully or partly denied (KFF)
80.7%
of appealed 2024 denials overturned (KFF)
Search for the worst Medicare Advantage plans and you will find lists that rank whole companies from good to bad. That rarely helps. A carrier can run a 4.5-star contract in one state and a 2.5-star contract in another, and the plan that fits your neighbor may be a poor match for your prescriptions. What you need is a way to spot a weak plan before you sign up.
This guide uses objective signals anyone can verify: Medicare’s own quality scores, the warning icon CMS puts on chronic low performers, published denial data and the letters plans must send when they are ending. If you want the background on how scores are built, see our guide to how Medicare Advantage star ratings work.
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison