Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 18, 2026
The worst Medicare Supplement companies for you are the ones with a weak financial strength rating, a complaint index well above 1.00, a pattern of steep yearly rate hikes, or a plan block that is closed to new buyers. Because every Plan G or Plan N pays the same benefits no matter who sells it, the insurer’s stability, pricing behavior and service record are the only real differences, and all of them can be checked with public data.
2027 by the Numbers
1.00
national average on the NAIC complaint index (share of complaints vs. share of premium)
~44,000
Medicare Supplement members affected when Allstate Health Solutions announced its Medigap exit in May 2025 (agency report)
51 / 0.83
complaints and index for Anthem Insurance Companies in Indiana’s 2025 health complaint index (Indiana DOI)
People search for a list of bad Medigap insurers hoping someone has already done the homework. The problem is that a carrier can be a poor fit in one state and a strong value in the next, and a rate spike in one ZIP code says little about another. A ranking that just names brands tends to be out of date the week it is published.
A better approach is to know the warning signs and look them up yourself. This guide walks through ten red flags, shows what real state complaint data looks like, and explains what to do if your current insurer starts showing them. If you want the positive side of the same research, see our page on best rated Medicare Supplement plans.
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison