Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 11, 2026
Medical Mutual Medicare Supplement plans are sold only to Ohio residents, and the company’s current Medicare Supplement page lists four plans: G, high-deductible G, N and K. Two people in one household who both hold a Medical Mutual policy each get 7.5% off the monthly premium, and an optional Supplement Plus policy adds dental, vision and hearing coverage for $28 a month.
2027 by the Numbers
7.5%
household discount on Medical Mutual’s Medicare Supplement page, updated Oct. 2026
19.3%
share of Ohio Medigap members at year-end 2024, second-largest in the state (NAIC via NerdWallet)
$28
monthly price of the optional Supplement Plus add-on (Medical Mutual)
Medical Mutual of Ohio is a mutual health insurer whose roots go back to a Cleveland hospital prepayment plan formed in 1934. It left the Blue Cross Blue Shield system in 1997 and took its current name. Today it is one of the biggest Medigap sellers in its home state, but it does not sell Medicare Supplement policies outside Ohio.
This page compares what Medical Mutual offers now with what its earlier brochure offered, and lays out the details Ohio shoppers need before requesting a quote. For the company’s Medicare Advantage side, see our Medical Mutual Medicare Advantage page.
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison