Christian Fidelity Medicare Supplement: Ownership, Rating and 15 Years of Kansas Rates

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 16, 2026

Christian Fidelity Medicare supplement plans are sold by Christian Fidelity Life Insurance Company of Dallas, Texas, a subsidiary of Phoenix-based Oxford Life Insurance Company, whose ultimate parent is U-Haul Holding Company; AM Best rates the group A (Excellent) with a negative outlook. State insurance records show the company in Medigap markets such as Texas, Kansas and Missouri, and available plan letters vary by state.

2027 by the Numbers

A

AM Best financial strength rating, Oxford Life and Christian Fidelity, affirmed Sept. 2025

$2,996.89

annual Plan F premium, male 69, ZIP 66502, effective Sept. 2025 (Kansas Insurance Dept.)

46%

rise in that Kansas Plan F premium from June 2018 to Sept. 2025 (our calculation)

Despite the name, Christian Fidelity is a stock insurance company, not a church group or fraternal society. It focuses on older buyers, selling final expense life insurance and Medicare supplement coverage, and it belongs to the Oxford Life family of insurers.

Because Christian Fidelity publishes little about its Medigap rates, we turned to the Kansas Insurance Department, whose public tool shows a premium history for each company. Those numbers, plus the company’s ownership and rating record, give a clearer view than a sales brochure. Texas readers can also compare carriers on our Medigap plans in Texas page.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Owned by Oxford Life Insurance Company, which is owned by U-Haul Holding Company

✔

AM Best A (Excellent) rating, outlook moved to negative in 2025

✔

Kansas records show steady yearly increases on Plan F since 2020

✔

No monthly direct-bill option on Kansas quotes; monthly payment is by bank draft

Compare plans and enroll online

The Company Chain Behind Your Policy

Level Company What it does
Ultimate parent U-Haul Holding Company (NYSE: UHAL) Moving and storage company that owns the insurance group
Insurance parent Oxford Life Insurance Company, Phoenix, Arizona Annuities, final expense and Medicare supplement, including through North American Insurance Company
Issuer Christian Fidelity Life Insurance Company, Dallas, Texas Issues Medigap and final expense policies; NAIC number 61859

Sources: AM Best releases (2023 and 2025) and the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance company record.

Oxford Life sells Medigap through two subsidiaries, so a quote from an Oxford-affiliated agent may come from either company. Check which insurer appears on the application and outline of coverage.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Reading the AM Best Rating and Outlook

AM Best rates Oxford Life and Christian Fidelity together as the Oxford Group. In August 2023 it affirmed an A (Excellent) financial strength rating with a stable outlook. In September 2025 it affirmed the A rating again but revised the outlook to negative.

Reason for the negative outlook: AM Best pointed to an internal control weakness in financial reporting and account reconciliation found during the 2023 statutory audit, which it said was only partly fixed. The rating itself stayed at A.

A negative outlook signals a possible downgrade, not a claims-paying problem. For context on how carriers stack up, see our list of the largest Medicare supplement companies.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Kansas Rate History: What the State's Tool Shows

The Kansas Insurance Department lists past premiums for one buyer profile using today’s rating factors, so the changes reflect rate actions rather than the buyer getting older. We pulled two Christian Fidelity profiles and worked out the yearly changes.

Effective date Plan F annual premium (male 69, ZIP 66502) Change from prior entry
June 2018 $2,047.79 No change from 2016
June 2020 $2,139.94 +4.5%
June 2021 $2,257.63 +5.5%
June 2022 $2,381.80 +5.5%
June 2023 $2,548.53 +7.0%
June 2024 $2,800.84 +9.9%
September 2025 $2,996.89 +7.0%

Our analysis of Kansas Insurance Department Medicare supplement shopper data, accessed November 2026. Plan F is open only to people eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020.

$1,328.70

Plan A annual premium, female 65, ZIP 66012, November 2010

$2,080.46

Same Plan A profile, effective September 2025

+57%

Total change over those 15 years

Plan Letters and Where You Can Buy

Christian Fidelity does not publish a state-by-state list. Here is what we could confirm from public records and its sales materials.

Confirmed so far

✔

Listed by the Texas Department of Insurance among Medigap companies (October 2025)

✔

Plans A and F appear in the Kansas rate tool, and the company is in the Kansas 2026 shopper’s guide

✔

Reported individual Medicare supplement premium in Missouri market share data

✔

A 2025 agency page markets Plans A, F, G and N

Plan G and Plan N are the usual choices for people new to Medicare. If a Christian Fidelity Plan N quote looks appealing, our page on Medicare supplement Plan N cost explains the copays you trade for the lower premium.

Payment Options and Pricing Method

Payment modes on Kansas quotes

✔

Annual

✔

Semi-annual

✔

Quarterly

✔

Monthly by automatic bank draft (Check-o-Matic)

✔

No monthly direct bill

Questions to ask before you apply

✔

Is the rate attained-age, issue-age or community-rated?

✔

Is there a household or spousal discount in my state?

✔

Which letters are open to new applicants here?

We could not confirm Christian Fidelity’s rating method or any household discount, so get those answers in writing. Our explainer on community-rated Medicare supplement plans shows why the pricing method matters over 20 years.

Compare plans and enroll online

How It Compares With Other Niche Carriers

Carrier Who owns it Medigap sales today
Christian Fidelity Life Oxford Life, owned by U-Haul Holding Company Active
SILAC Insurance Company SILAC, Inc.; Hildene purchase announced Dec. 2025 Stopped new Medigap sales in 2020
GCU Member-owned fraternal society in Pennsylvania Small closed block, per AM Best in 2022
Members Health Insurance Co. Tennessee Rural Health Improvement Association group Active, tied to Michigan and Indiana Farm Bureaus

Our comparison from AM Best, company and state insurance department sources.

Getting a Christian Fidelity Quote

1

Confirm the issuing company Make sure the quote is from Christian Fidelity, not a sister company.

2

Pick the same letter everywhere Compare Plan G to Plan G, or Plan N to Plan N.

3

Look up your state’s rate history Kansas and some other states publish past premiums by company.

4

Check the bank-draft requirement Monthly payment may require automatic withdrawal.

5

Apply during open enrollment if possible Your first six months with Part B give guaranteed acceptance.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Christian Fidelity is a Dallas-based Oxford Life subsidiary owned ultimately by U-Haul Holding Company, with an AM Best A rating now on negative outlook. Kansas data shows Plan F rising every year since 2020, so compare rate history as well as the first-year premium. Confirm letters, pricing method and discounts in your state before applying.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Is Christian Fidelity a religious organization?

No. It is a stock life and health insurer owned by Oxford Life Insurance Company. The name reflects its history, not a church membership requirement.

➤ Who is Christian Fidelity’s parent company?

Oxford Life Insurance Company of Phoenix, which is owned by U-Haul Holding Company.

➤ Is Christian Fidelity financially strong?

AM Best rates the Oxford Group, including Christian Fidelity, A (Excellent). In September 2025 the outlook was revised to negative because of a financial reporting control issue.

➤ How much have Christian Fidelity premiums gone up?

In Kansas, Plan F for a 69-year-old man in ZIP 66502 went from $2,047.79 in June 2018 to $2,996.89 in September 2025, about 46%. Other states and plans will differ.

➤ Can I pay my Christian Fidelity premium monthly?

Kansas quotes show monthly payment only through automatic bank draft. Annual, semi-annual and quarterly billing are also listed.

➤ Does Christian Fidelity sell Plan G?

An agency page from 2025 markets Plan G along with A, F and N. Availability depends on your state, so confirm before applying.

➤ Is Christian Fidelity related to Bankers Fidelity?

No. Bankers Fidelity is a separate company with different owners. The similar names are a coincidence.

➤ What states does Christian Fidelity sell Medigap in?

The company does not publish a list. We confirmed it in Texas and Kansas state records and in Missouri market data; ask about your ZIP code.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company