Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 16, 2026
Christian Fidelity Medicare supplement plans are sold by Christian Fidelity Life Insurance Company of Dallas, Texas, a subsidiary of Phoenix-based Oxford Life Insurance Company, whose ultimate parent is U-Haul Holding Company; AM Best rates the group A (Excellent) with a negative outlook. State insurance records show the company in Medigap markets such as Texas, Kansas and Missouri, and available plan letters vary by state.
2027 by the Numbers
A
AM Best financial strength rating, Oxford Life and Christian Fidelity, affirmed Sept. 2025
$2,996.89
annual Plan F premium, male 69, ZIP 66502, effective Sept. 2025 (Kansas Insurance Dept.)
46%
rise in that Kansas Plan F premium from June 2018 to Sept. 2025 (our calculation)
Despite the name, Christian Fidelity is a stock insurance company, not a church group or fraternal society. It focuses on older buyers, selling final expense life insurance and Medicare supplement coverage, and it belongs to the Oxford Life family of insurers.
Because Christian Fidelity publishes little about its Medigap rates, we turned to the Kansas Insurance Department, whose public tool shows a premium history for each company. Those numbers, plus the company’s ownership and rating record, give a clearer view than a sales brochure. Texas readers can also compare carriers on our Medigap plans in Texas page.
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison