Everence Medicare Supplement: A Fraternal Insurer's Medigap Plans and Pricing Choice

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 3, 2026

Everence Medicare Supplement plans are issued by Everence Association, Inc., a member-owned fraternal benefit society in Goshen, Indiana, and are sold in 18 states including Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Kansas and Florida. Plan letters vary by state; in Pennsylvania they include A, F, G, L and N, and Everence quotes both issue-age and attained-age premiums.

2027 by the Numbers

18

states on Everence’s Medicare Supplement state list (Everence)

1945

year Everence was founded; Medigap since the mid-1980s (Everence)

April 1

date Everence’s new Medigap rates take effect each year (Everence)

Most Medigap shoppers compare big national insurers and never hear of Everence. It is a fraternal benefit society, a member-owned organization rather than a stock company, and it has sold Medicare supplement coverage since the mid-1980s after entering health insurance in 1965.

What sets Everence apart on a quote is not the benefits, which are standardized, but the way it lets you choose how your premium is calculated. This page covers its states, plan letters, that pricing choice and the member programs that come with the policy. Our refresher on how Medigap premiums are calculated is useful background.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Issued by Everence Association, Inc., a fraternal benefit society

✔

Sold in 18 states, from California to Maryland

✔

Pennsylvania lineup includes Plans A, F, G, L and N

✔

Offers both issue-age and attained-age quotes

Compare plans and enroll online

Where Everence Sells Medigap

Region States on Everence’s list
West Arizona, California, Colorado, Montana, Oregon
Plains Kansas, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Iowa
Midwest Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio
East and South Florida, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Virginia

Grouped by us from the state selector on Everence’s Medicare supplement page. Availability and plan letters vary within each state.

The list leans toward the Midwest and Plains, but it also reaches the West Coast and the Mid-Atlantic. Within a state, the letters offered and the rate classes can differ, so the quote for your ZIP code is the only reliable check.

Not national: Everence says its plans are not available in all states, so residents of states outside this list need another carrier.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

The Pricing Choice Few Carriers Give You

Most Medigap insurers price plans one way. Everence states that while most insurers only offer attained-age quotes, it offers both attained-age and issue-age. That gives buyers a decision to make at the start.

Neither method freezes your premium. Both can rise when medical costs and claims go up across the plan. The difference is whether getting older, on its own, pushes your rate higher. With issue-age pricing, a 65-year-old who buys today keeps the age-65 factor; with attained-age pricing, the factor follows each new birthday or age band.

Issue-age quote

✔

Age factor set by your age at purchase

✔

Tends to cost more at 65

✔

Does not rise just because you have a birthday

✔

Can still rise for inflation and claims

Attained-age quote

✔

Age factor follows your current age

✔

Tends to cost less at 65

✔

Steps up as you get older

✔

Also rises for inflation and claims

Our guide to issue-age Medicare Supplement plans shows how the two methods tend to cross over after several years.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Plan Letters Everence Files

Letters differ by state. Pennsylvania is a good example of the full range Everence files.

Plan Pennsylvania Notes
A Yes Basic benefits only
F Yes Only for people first eligible for Medicare before 2020
G Yes Everything F covers except the Part B deductible
L Yes Pays 75% of most cost-sharing, with a yearly cap
N Yes Part B copays of up to $20 and $50

From Everence’s Pennsylvania Medicare supplement page. Other states may differ.

Plan L is unusual on a carrier’s menu. If you want lower premiums but a safety net, compare it with our page on Medicare Supplement Plan L.

2026 cost you still pay Plan G Plan N Plan L
Part B deductible ($283) Yes Yes Yes
Part A deductible ($1,736) No No 25%
Office visit copays No Up to $20 25% coinsurance
Yearly out-of-pocket cap Not needed None $4,000

Standardized benefits; 2026 Medicare amounts from CMS. Plan L cap from 2026 insurer outlines of coverage.

Options for People Under 65

Everence notes specific state rules for people on Medicare because of a disability.

Colorado

All standardized plans offered to disabled Medicare enrollees, any age

Maryland

Plan A for under-65 disabled enrollees

Virginia

Plan A for under-65 disabled enrollees

Fact: Federal law does not require Medigap insurers to sell to people under 65, so state rules like Colorado’s matter a great deal for disabled enrollees.

Member Programs Tied to the Policy

A fraternal benefit society is a member-based organization that provides insurance to its members and also runs community and charitable programs. Everence was founded in 1945, entered health insurance in 1965 and added Medicare supplement plans in the mid-1980s.

Everence Association member benefits

✔

A wellness benefit

✔

A will preparation benefit

✔

Access to the Sharing Fund, a community program that helps people in need

Everence says these member benefits are not insurance and can be discontinued at any time. They are extras attached to membership in the fraternal association, not part of your Medigap coverage.

Compare plans and enroll online

Rate Timing and Underwriting Points

1

New rates each April 1 Everence typically posts the next year’s rates in late February.

2

Tobacco can cost more Everence notes that rates may be higher for tobacco users.

3

Location matters Premiums vary by where you live, so quote by ZIP code.

4

Open enrollment protects you In your first six months with Part B at 65 or older, health questions cannot be used to deny you.

Smart move: Ask for both an issue-age and an attained-age quote for the same letter, then compare them with what at least two other carriers charge.

Everence’s state pages ask for your ZIP code, gender, birthdate and the date you want coverage to start before showing a quote. Having your Medicare card handy with your Part A and Part B start dates speeds up an application, since open enrollment timing depends on your Part B date.

Who Everence Fits

Worth a quote if you

✔

Live in one of the 18 listed states

✔

Want the option of issue-age pricing to limit age-based increases

✔

Like the idea of a member-owned organization

✔

Are considering Plan L as a middle path

Everence may be a weaker fit if you want the widest choice of plan letters in one place, or if you live outside its 18 states. Because benefits are identical by letter, the deciding factors are the long-term premium path and how comfortable you are with a smaller, member-owned insurer.

If Everence does not serve your state, our list of the largest Medicare Supplement companies covers insurers with wider reach.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Everence Medicare Supplement coverage comes from a member-owned fraternal benefit society that has sold Medigap since the mid-1980s in a limited set of states. Its standout feature is letting you choose issue-age or attained-age pricing, so ask for both quotes and compare them with other carriers before you apply.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Who issues Everence Medicare Supplement plans?

Everence Association, Inc., a fraternal benefit society based in Goshen, Indiana. Everence is its marketing name.

➤ Which states have Everence Medigap?

Everence lists 18 states: Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Michigan, Montana, Nebraska, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Dakota and Virginia.

➤ Does Everence offer issue-age Medigap pricing?

Yes. Everence says it offers both issue-age and attained-age quotes, while most insurers offer only attained-age.

➤ What plans does Everence sell in Pennsylvania?

Plans A, F, G, L and N. Plan F is only for people first eligible for Medicare before 2020.

➤ When do Everence Medigap rates change?

New rates take effect April 1 each year and are typically posted in late February.

➤ Is the Everence wellness benefit part of my Medigap coverage?

No. It is a membership benefit of the fraternal association, is not insurance and can be discontinued.

➤ Can I buy Everence Medigap if I am under 65?

It depends on your state. Colorado offers all standardized plans to disabled enrollees, while Maryland and Virginia offer Plan A to people under 65.

➤ Is a fraternal Medigap plan different from a regular one?

The benefits are not. Every Medigap plan of the same letter covers the same costs; the difference is in pricing, service and membership extras.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company