LifeShield Medicare Supplement Review: Ratings History, Discounts and Plan Choices

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 6, 2026

LifeShield Medicare Supplement plans are issued by LifeShield National Insurance Co., a small Oklahoma City insurer rated B++ (Good) by AM Best, and are often among the lower-priced Plan G quotes in the states where it sells. The tradeoffs are a narrower plan menu in some states, attained-age pricing in at least some markets, and a rating one notch below the A range.

2027 by the Numbers

B++

AM Best financial strength rating, outlook stable since July 2025

7%

household premium discount where approved (carrier)

1982

year LifeShield National was founded (carrier)

19

states at launch of its Medigap and dental-vision-hearing combo, April 2023

LifeShield is the kind of carrier that surprises people on a quote sheet. It is a regional company most shoppers have never heard of, yet its Plan G price can land near the bottom of the list. The natural question is whether a low price from a lesser-known insurer is a bargain or a warning sign.

Below is what public filings and rating releases show about the company, including a ratings outlook that moved twice in two years. Because Medigap benefits are standardized, the price you pay and how it grows over time matter more than the logo. Our Medicare Supplement comparison guide covers that side in detail.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Home office in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

✔

Part of a small group that also includes Individual Assurance Company, Life, Health & Accident

✔

B++ rating with a stable outlook after two years on negative watch

✔

Can be bundled with a dental, vision and hearing policy for a multi-product discount

Compare plans and enroll online

The LifeShield Family of Companies

LifeShield National Insurance Co. was formed in 1982, according to the company, and started out selling supplemental coverage tied to homeowners. Today it writes Medicare Supplement, supplemental accident and health, life and final expense products.

Who is in the group

✔

LifeShield National Insurance Co., the Medigap issuer

✔

Individual Assurance Company, Life, Health & Accident (IAC), bought by LifeShield under a 2019 agreement

✔

Life Assurance Company, listed by LifeShield as an affiliate

All of these companies are based in Oklahoma City. AM Best rates LifeShield and IAC together as one group.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

AM Best Rating Timeline

Most reviews print a single grade. The history behind it says more about where the company has been. Here is the sequence pulled from AM Best’s own press releases.

Date AM Best action Stated reason
June 2019 B++ placed under review with developing implications LifeShield agreed to buy IAC for cash
December 2022 LifeShield B++ affirmed; IAC upgraded Group rated together after the deal
July 2023 Outlooks revised to negative; B++ kept Worksite product line with high loss ratios
July 2025 Outlooks revised to stable; B++ affirmed Results improved after 2023 rate increases on that line

Built from AM Best releases carried by Business Wire and InsuranceNewsNet. The 2023-2025 concern involved worksite products, not Medigap.

Reading the grade: B++ is the fifth-highest of AM Best’s 16 ratings and means Good financial strength. It sits just below A- (Excellent), the level many large Medigap carriers hold.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Plans and Pricing Style

LifeShield sells standardized Medigap letters, but the lineup is set state by state. A 2026 MoneyGeek review of Ohio carriers listed only Plans A, F and G for LifeShield there, with no Plan N and no high-deductible option, and noted attained-age pricing.

Plan G

The core product in most states; covers all gaps except the Part B deductible

Plan A

Basic benefits only, for buyers watching every dollar

Plan F

Only for people eligible for Medicare before 2020

Other letters

Vary by state; check the outline of coverage

Attained-age pricing means your premium is tied to your current age and steps up as you get older, on top of any general rate changes. Learn how the three rating methods differ in our guide to how Medigap premiums are calculated.

Low first-year price: A low entry premium on an attained-age policy can climb faster over ten years than an issue-age policy that starts higher. Ask for both the current rate and the company’s rate change history in your state.

Discounts and the Dental-Vision-Hearing Combo

LifeShield advertises a 7% household discount, though it is not offered in every state. In April 2023 it also teamed with AmeriLife to sell a Medicare Supplement policy together with a separate dental, vision and hearing (DVH) policy.

Household discount

✔

7% off the Medigap premium

✔

Not available in all states

✔

Rules on who counts as a household member vary

DVH combo

✔

Separate policy sold alongside Medigap

✔

Approved Medigap clients qualify for a multi-product discount on DVH

✔

Launched in 19 states, with more planned

Original Medicare and Medigap do not pay for routine dental, eyeglasses or hearing aids, so a paired DVH policy fills a real gap. Compare its cost and waiting periods with stand-alone dental plans before you add it.

Where LifeShield Is Sold

LifeShield’s public announcements do not include a full state list, so availability has to be checked state by state. LifeShield appears on Indiana’s state health insurance assistance program list of approved Medigap carriers dated April 2025, and a 2026 MoneyGeek review shows it selling in Ohio.

1

Check your state insurance department Most states publish a list of approved Medigap carriers and plan letters.

2

Ask an independent agent for a quote LifeShield markets through independent agents and marketing groups such as AmeriLife.

3

Request the outline of coverage It shows the plan letters, rating method and discounts approved in your state.

Compare plans and enroll online

Pros and Cons at a Glance

Why people pick it

✔

Plan G often priced near the low end of quotes

✔

Same Medicare-approved doctors as any other Medigap plan

✔

Household and combo discounts

✔

Smaller company with a personal service model

What to weigh

✔

B++ rating, below the A range

✔

Fewer plan letters in some states

✔

Attained-age pricing in at least some states

✔

Limited public information on rate history

If you want a carrier with a top-tier rating, look at the national names first and use LifeShield as a price check. If price is your main concern and you are healthy enough to switch later, it may be worth a quote.

Before You Apply

A short checklist

✔

Confirm the policy is issued by LifeShield National Insurance Co. and not a different company

✔

Ask whether pricing is attained-age, issue-age or community-rated in your state

✔

Ask what share of the household discount applies and who qualifies

✔

Apply during your six-month Medigap open enrollment period if you can, when health questions cannot be used to turn you down

✔

Keep your old coverage until the new policy is approved and active

Benefits by letter are the same at every company. See our Medicare Supplement plans overview for what each letter pays in 2027.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

LifeShield is a small Oklahoma City insurer with a B++ rating that often prices Plan G competitively. Its rating outlook returned to stable in 2025, but plan choices and pricing style vary by state. Get its rate history and compare it with an A-rated carrier before you decide.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Is LifeShield a good Medicare Supplement company?

LifeShield holds a B++ (Good) rating from AM Best and often has low Plan G prices. It is a smaller company, so weigh its price against its rate history and rating.

➤ Where is LifeShield National Insurance located?

LifeShield National Insurance Co. is based in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, as are its affiliate companies.

➤ Why did AM Best put LifeShield on a negative outlook?

In July 2023 AM Best cited high loss ratios in a worksite product line. After rate increases on that line, it moved the outlook back to stable in July 2025.

➤ Does LifeShield offer Plan N?

It depends on the state. A 2026 review of Ohio listed only Plans A, F and G for LifeShield there, so check the outline of coverage for your state.

➤ What is the LifeShield household discount?

LifeShield advertises a 7% household discount. It is not available in all states, and eligibility rules can differ.

➤ Can I get dental coverage with a LifeShield Medigap plan?

LifeShield sells a separate dental, vision and hearing policy that can be bundled with its Medigap plan for a multi-product discount.

➤ Who owns Individual Assurance Company?

LifeShield National agreed in 2019 to buy Individual Assurance Company, Life, Health & Accident, another Oklahoma City insurer, and AM Best now rates them as a group.

➤ Will my LifeShield premium go up as I age?

Where the policy uses attained-age pricing, yes. The premium rises with your age as well as with any approved rate changes.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company