Medicare Supplement Plan J in 2027: Keep Your Legacy Plan or Move On?

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 18, 2026

Medicare Supplement Plan J has not been sold to new buyers since June 1, 2010, but anyone who already has it can keep it for life as long as they pay the premium. Plan J pays both Medicare deductibles, skilled nursing coinsurance, excess charges and foreign travel emergencies, plus two extras later dropped from all plans; its drug coverage only remains on policies issued before 2006 for people not enrolled in Part D.

2027 by the Numbers

June 1, 2010

date Plan J stopped being sold to new buyers (state insurance notices)

Dec 31, 2005

last day a Medigap policy with drug coverage could be sold (CMS)

$2,400

2027 Part D out-of-pocket cap, which old Medigap drug benefits never had (CMS)

Plan J was once the top of the Medigap ladder. For years it was the richest standardized plan, with extras no other letter had. Two law changes reshaped it: Medicare Part D arrived in 2006, and the Medigap lineup was redesigned on June 1, 2010, when Plans E, H, I and J were retired.

If you still carry Plan J, you have a policy nobody can buy anymore. That has real upsides and some quiet costs. This page explains what you have, how it compares with today’s plans and how to decide whether to stay. For the current plan lineup, see our list of Medicare Supplement plans.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

No new Plan J policies since June 1, 2010

✔

Existing Plan J is guaranteed renewable and keeps its original benefits

✔

Drug coverage survives only on pre-2006 policies for people without Part D

✔

Every Plan J holder can still choose Plan F, since all were on Medicare before 2020

Compare plans and enroll online

What Plan J Pays That Most Plans Never Did

Plan J benefits on policies still in force

✔

Part A deductible ($1,736 per benefit period in 2026) and hospital coinsurance

✔

Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) and Part B coinsurance

✔

Skilled nursing facility coinsurance

✔

100% of Part B excess charges

✔

Foreign travel emergency care, with lifetime limits

✔

At-home recovery help after an illness or surgery

✔

A small preventive care allowance

The last two items were removed from every Medigap plan in the 2010 redesign. State regulators explained that at-home recovery was rarely used and that Medicare itself had expanded preventive coverage. Policies sold before the change kept them, which is why Plan J still lists them.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Timeline: How Plan J Was Phased Out

Date Change Effect on Plan J
January 1, 2006 Medicare Part D begins No new Medigap drug coverage can be sold; Plan J sold after this date has no drug benefit
2006 onward Holders choose Part D or old drug coverage Joining Part D means dropping the Medigap drug benefit
June 1, 2010 Medigap lineup redesigned Plans E, H, I and J, including high-deductible J, closed to new buyers; Plans M and N added
January 1, 2020 Plans C and F close to newly eligible people No change for Plan J holders, who were all on Medicare before 2020

Sources: CMS Medigap guidance and state insurance department notices on the 2010 changes.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

The Drug Benefit: History and the Part D Trap

Under the original standard design, Plan J’s drug benefit had its own $250 deductible and then paid half of drug costs up to a yearly cap. CMS confirmed that only Plan J policies in effect before January 1, 2006 can carry that benefit, and only for people who are not enrolled in Medicare drug coverage.

Late penalty risk: CMS has said that in most cases Medigap drug coverage does not count as creditable coverage. If you kept the old Plan J drug benefit instead of joining Part D, enrolling in Part D now could come with a permanent late enrollment penalty.

Feature Old Plan J drug benefit Part D plan in 2027
Deductible $250, separate from medical Up to $700, depending on the plan
Yearly protection Capped benefit; you pay everything above it $2,400 out-of-pocket cap on covered drugs
Counts as creditable coverage Usually not Yes
Can you have both? No. Joining Part D requires dropping it No

Part D figures are 2027 CMS amounts. Old drug benefit details from CMS Medigap guidance.

For more on how Medigap and drugs fit together, see do Medigap plans cover drugs.

Plan J Compared With Today's Plan F and Plan G

Benefit Plan J (legacy) Plan F Plan G
Part A deductible Yes Yes Yes
Part B deductible Yes Yes No
Skilled nursing coinsurance Yes Yes Yes
Part B excess charges Yes Yes Yes
Foreign travel emergency Yes Yes Yes
Hospice coinsurance Not a listed basic benefit on older policies Yes Yes
At-home recovery and preventive extras Yes No No
Who can buy it Nobody new Only if eligible before 2020 Anyone

On medical bills, Plan J and Plan F are very close. The 2010 redesign added hospice coinsurance to the basic benefits of newer plans, which older policies did not list. Our Medicare Supplement Plan F page has more on F.

Why Your Plan J Premium May Keep Climbing

Plan J has been closed to new members for more than 16 years. That means every Plan J pool is made up of people who joined Medicare before mid-2010, and the group gets older each year. Older groups usually file more claims, so premiums in closed plans often rise faster than in plans still adding younger members. We do not cite specific increase figures because they vary by insurer and state.

16+ years

Since Plan J last took new buyers

0

New members joining any Plan J pool

Pre-2010

When every current holder joined Medicare

Compare plans and enroll online

Keep Plan J or Switch: A Decision Guide

Reasons to keep Plan J

✔

Your health might not pass new underwriting

✔

Your premium is still reasonable

✔

You value the at-home recovery benefit

✔

You want first-dollar coverage with no deductibles

Reasons to compare plans

✔

Your premium has jumped in recent years

✔

You are healthy enough to pass health questions

✔

Plan G with the Part B deductible may cost less overall

✔

You still hold old drug coverage and need a Part D cap

1

Add up your yearly Plan J premium Compare it with quotes for Plan F and Plan G in your ZIP code.

2

Price the Part B deductible If Plan G saves more than the $283 deductible ($292 for 2027), it may be the better deal.

3

Check your health honestly Most moves need underwriting. Apply and get approved before cancelling Plan J.

4

Look for state switching rights Some states offer birthday rules or yearly windows; see our page on switching without underwriting.

One Option Plan J Holders Have That Others Do Not

Plan F is closed to anyone who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. Because no one has been able to buy Plan J since June 2010, every current Plan J holder was on Medicare well before 2020. That means all of them may still apply for Plan F, which comes closest to Plan J’s medical coverage.

Do not lapse coverage: Once you cancel Plan J, you can never get it back. Keep it active until a replacement policy is approved and in force.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Plan J has been closed to new buyers since June 1, 2010, but existing holders can keep it with all its original benefits for as long as they pay. Because the pool keeps aging, it pays to compare Plan F or Plan G quotes now and then, but never drop Plan J before a new policy is approved.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Can I still buy Medicare Supplement Plan J?

No. Plan J closed to new buyers on June 1, 2010. Only people who bought it before then can keep it.

➤ Will my insurer cancel my Plan J?

No. Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable, so your insurer cannot drop you while you pay your premium.

➤ Does Plan J still cover prescription drugs?

Only on policies issued before January 1, 2006, and only if you are not enrolled in Part D. Joining Part D means giving up that drug benefit.

➤ Is Plan J drug coverage creditable for Part D?

In most cases, no. CMS has said Medigap drug coverage usually is not creditable, so delaying Part D can lead to a late penalty.

➤ What is the difference between Plan J and Plan F?

Both pay the Part A and Part B deductibles and nearly all other gaps. Plan J also has at-home recovery and preventive care extras that were dropped in 2010.

➤ Can a Plan J holder switch to Plan F?

Yes, you may apply, since all Plan J holders were on Medicare before 2020. Outside special rights, the insurer can ask health questions.

➤ Why is my Plan J premium so high?

Plan J pools have taken no new members since 2010, so they keep getting older. Premiums may rise faster than in plans still open to new buyers.

➤ Was there a high-deductible Plan J?

Yes. A high-deductible version of Plan J was sold too, and it was also closed to new buyers on June 1, 2010.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company