Transamerica Medicare Supplement Reviews for Current Policyholders

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 14, 2026

Transamerica Medicare Supplement reviews now matter mainly to existing policyholders, because Transamerica stopped new sales of its agent-sold Medigap plans on September 28, 2020, and in May 2026 stopped issuing individual policies in New York. Existing policies remain renewable and are backed by Transamerica Life Insurance Company, which AM Best rated A (Excellent) with a stable outlook in February 2026.

2027 by the Numbers

Sept. 28, 2020

end of new sales for agent-sold Transamerica Medigap Plans A through N

A (Excellent)

AM Best rating for Transamerica Life Insurance Company, stable outlook, Feb. 2026

May 2026

Transamerica stopped issuing individual Medigap policies in New York (local press report)

If you search for Transamerica Medigap reviews, most of what you find was written for shoppers. That audience has mostly gone away. Transamerica closed its agent-sold line years ago, and its remaining individual sales have been shrinking, so the people who need a review today are the ones already paying a Transamerica premium.

This page reviews Transamerica from that seat: how secure your coverage is, what tends to happen to prices in a policy block that no longer adds new members, and how to tell when it is time to compare. For the sales timeline and your switching options in detail, see our Transamerica Medicare Supplement overview.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Transamerica’s notice said in-force policies would keep being supported and renewed.

✔

Its life insurer kept an A (Excellent) AM Best rating in early 2026.

✔

A closed policy block can face steeper price pressure over time.

✔

In New York, a press report said group coverage through certain member organizations was still being offered.

Compare plans and enroll online

Reading a Review When You Cannot Buy the Product

A normal Medigap review weighs price, service and stability to help you choose. When a carrier stops selling, the question flips. You are no longer asking whether to buy, but whether to stay.

Review factor For a new shopper For a current Transamerica policyholder
Opening premium Main deciding factor No longer relevant; your renewal price is what counts
Rate-increase pattern A guess about the future Your direct cost every year you stay
Financial strength Will the insurer be there? Still matters, since claims run through the same company
Health questions Avoided during open enrollment Decide whether you could pass underwriting to switch
Customer service Hard to judge in advance You already know your own claims experience

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Is Your Coverage Safe?

Yes. Medigap policies sold since 1992 are guaranteed renewable, which means the insurer cannot cancel you for health reasons as long as you pay the premium and told the truth on your application. Transamerica’s 2020 notice to agents said existing in-force policies would not be affected and that clients could still renew.

A

AM Best Financial Strength Rating, Transamerica Life Insurance Company

Stable

outlook in AM Best’s February 2026 release

Aegon

parent group of Transamerica’s U.S. insurers

Plain fact: Your benefits do not shrink because sales closed. A Transamerica Plan G pays the same standardized benefits it paid on the day it was issued.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Why Closed Blocks Can See Bigger Increases

Insurers price Medigap in groups of similar policies, called blocks. When a block stops taking new members, everyone in it keeps getting older and, on average, files more claims. With no younger, healthier members joining to balance the pool, premiums in a closed block can rise faster than in an open one.

Signs your block may be under pressure

✔

Renewal increases noticeably larger than what friends with other carriers report

✔

Back-to-back increases in consecutive years

✔

Increases that outpace the age-based bump you were expecting

Not a certainty: We found no published Transamerica rate history to quote, and increases vary by state and plan. A closed block raises the odds of steeper changes but does not guarantee them.

The New York Change in 2026

A June 2026 senior news column in western New York reported that Transamerica stopped issuing individual Medicare Supplement policies in the state in May 2026. The same column said Transamerica coverage was still available through group arrangements for members of certain organizations, such as some veterans and fraternal groups.

Verify locally: This comes from one local report, not a carrier notice. If you live in New York and were offered group coverage, ask the organization or Transamerica directly for the current terms.

New York also gives Medigap buyers year-round open enrollment and community rating, which means a New York policyholder can usually move to another carrier without medical underwriting.

When to Start Comparing

1

Read every renewal letter Note the new premium and the percentage change from last year.

2

Get same-letter quotes Price your exact plan letter from two or three other carriers so the benefits match.

3

Check your state’s switching rules Some states have birthday or anniversary rules that let you change plans without health questions.

4

Do not cancel early Keep the Transamerica policy active until a new policy is approved and in force.

Holding Plan F? Our cost of Medicare Supplement Plan F page shows what to expect from Plan F pricing as that group ages.

Compare plans and enroll online

Staying vs. Leaving: The Tradeoffs

Reasons to stay

✔

Coverage is guaranteed renewable

✔

No underwriting risk

✔

Highly rated insurer stands behind claims

✔

Plan F holders may not find the same letter elsewhere if health has changed

Reasons to shop

✔

Closed-block pricing may climb faster

✔

A younger, open block elsewhere may cost less

✔

Plan G or N from another carrier may cover nearly the same for less

If you are weighing a move from Plan F, our page on the difference between Plan G and Plan F breaks down what you would give up.

Questions to Ask Transamerica Customer Service

Useful questions for a service call

✔

Which plan letter and policy form do I have?

✔

Is my policy priced by issue age, attained age or community rating?

✔

What were the rate changes on my policy form in the last three years?

✔

Is there a household or payment-method discount I am not using?

✔

Does my policy include any extras beyond standard Medigap benefits?

Write down the answers. They make it much easier to compare a quote from another carrier on equal terms.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Transamerica is no longer a carrier you can shop for in most cases, but your existing policy stays renewable and is backed by an A-rated insurer. The real review question is price over time, so watch each renewal and compare same-letter quotes whenever an increase stings.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Can I still buy a Transamerica Medicare Supplement?

For most people, no. Transamerica closed agent-sold Medigap sales on September 28, 2020, and a 2026 New York report said it stopped issuing individual policies there in May 2026, though some group coverage through member organizations was reported.

➤ Will Transamerica drop my Medigap coverage?

No. Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable, and Transamerica told agents that existing policies would keep being supported and renewed.

➤ Is Transamerica financially stable enough to keep my policy?

AM Best affirmed an A (Excellent) Financial Strength Rating with a stable outlook for Transamerica Life Insurance Company in February 2026.

➤ What is a closed block of business?

It is a group of policies that no longer accepts new members. As the existing members age, claims tend to rise, which can lead to larger premium increases than in blocks still adding new people.

➤ Should I switch away from Transamerica after a rate increase?

Compare first. Get quotes for the same plan letter and confirm you can pass any health questions before you cancel your current policy.

➤ Do Transamerica reviews from before 2020 still apply?

Only partly. Older reviews focused on new-buyer pricing, which no longer applies. Financial strength and service still matter to current policyholders.

➤ I live in New York. Is it easier for me to switch?

Usually yes. New York has year-round Medigap open enrollment and community rating, so insurers there generally cannot turn you down for health reasons.

➤ Who owns Transamerica?

Transamerica’s U.S. insurers belong to Aegon, the international insurance group. AM Best rates them as members of Aegon’s U.S. subsidiaries.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company