Worst Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027: Red Flags You Can Check Yourself

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 31, 2026

The worst Medicare Advantage plans are the ones with low CMS star ratings (especially contracts flagged with the low performer icon for scoring under 3 stars three years in a row), a network that leaves out your doctors, and drug or prior authorization rules that block the care you use. No single company is the worst everywhere, because every plan is rated by contract and sold county by county, so you have to check the exact plan in your ZIP code.

2027 by the Numbers

5,481

individual Medicare Advantage plans for 2027 (our analysis of CMS 2027 plan data)

32

contracts rated 2.5 stars or lower in the 2027 Star Ratings, up from 23 (CMS data via Becker’s)

7.7%

of 2024 prior authorization requests fully or partly denied (KFF)

80.7%

of appealed 2024 denials overturned (KFF)

Search for the worst Medicare Advantage plans and you will find lists that rank whole companies from good to bad. That rarely helps. A carrier can run a 4.5-star contract in one state and a 2.5-star contract in another, and the plan that fits your neighbor may be a poor match for your prescriptions. What you need is a way to spot a weak plan before you sign up.

This guide uses objective signals anyone can verify: Medicare’s own quality scores, the warning icon CMS puts on chronic low performers, published denial data and the letters plans must send when they are ending. If you want the background on how scores are built, see our guide to how Medicare Advantage star ratings work.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Weak plans are identified by contract and county, not by brand name

✔

A low performer icon means under 3 stars for at least three straight years

✔

Most appealed prior authorization denials in 2024 were overturned

✔

A plan that is ending for 2027 gives you a special window to switch

Compare plans and enroll online

Why There Is No Single Worst Plan

Medicare Advantage is sold through thousands of separate plan packages. Our count of the CMS 2027 plan files finds 5,481 individual plans spread across 3,131 counties. Each plan sits under a contract, and CMS scores the contract, not the parent company. That is why one insurer can show up near the top and the bottom of the same ratings release.

46%

of 2027 plans are HMOs (our analysis of CMS 2027 plan data)

33%

are PPOs, which usually allow some out-of-network care

36%

are special needs plans with eligibility rules

3,131

counties with at least one plan for 2027

Our analysis of CMS 2027 plan data: Nearly half of 2027 plans are HMOs. An HMO is not a bad plan, but it becomes a bad plan for you if your specialist or hospital is outside its network, so plan type matters as much as the rating.

Advertisement

Medicare Advantage Plan Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Red Flag 1: Low Star Ratings and the Low Performer Icon

CMS released the 2027 Star Ratings on October 8, 2026. Industry coverage of the CMS data reports that 32 contracts landed at 2.5 stars or fewer, up from 23 the year before, and the lowest score given was 2 stars. About 71% of people in plans with drug coverage are in contracts rated 4 stars or higher, so a low-rated plan is the exception, not the rule.

Rating signal What it tells you What you can do
4 to 5 stars Strong scores on care quality, member experience and drug plan measures Still check doctors, drugs and costs
3 to 3.5 stars Average performance; some measures may be weak Open the measure-level scores on Plan Finder
2.5 stars or lower Below-average results on many measures Compare at least two higher-rated plans first
Low performer icon Overall rating below 3 stars for three or more years in a row You may qualify for a one-time switch to a plan rated 3 stars or higher

Ratings apply to the whole contract. New plans may show “not enough data” instead of a score.

The low performer icon is the closest thing Medicare has to an official warning label. Medicare Rights Center guidance explains that members of these plans get a one-time special enrollment period, handled by Medicare, to move to a plan rated 3 stars or higher or to Original Medicare. For the full 2027 results, see our breakdown of Medicare Advantage star ratings for 2027.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Red Flag 2: A Network That Leaves Out Your Care

A plan with great scores can still be the wrong plan if it does not contract with the doctors you see. Networks are drawn plan by plan, and a carrier may use a smaller network in one product to keep premiums low.

Network warning signs

✔

Your primary care doctor or main specialist is not listed for the 2027 plan year

✔

The nearest in-network hospital is much farther than the one you use now

✔

Referrals are required for every specialist visit and your specialists are spread across systems

✔

Out-of-network care is covered only for emergencies and you travel often

✔

The provider directory shows offices that are not taking new patients

Call the doctor’s billing office to confirm the exact plan name, because directories can lag. Our page on Medicare Advantage network types explains how HMO, PPO and HMO-POS rules differ.

Red Flag 3: Prior Authorization and Denial Patterns

Most Medicare Advantage plans require approval before certain services. That is normal, but how often requests are denied varies by insurer. KFF’s review of 2024 data found nearly 53 million prior authorization decisions, with 7.7% fully or partly denied. Only 11.5% of denials were appealed, yet 80.7% of those appeals were overturned.

Insurer (parent company) Share of 2024 prior authorization requests denied
Elevance Health 4.2% (lowest reported)
Humana 5.8%
Centene 12.3%
UnitedHealth Group 12.8% (highest reported)

Source: KFF analysis of 2024 Medicare Advantage data. Rates are company-wide and do not predict how a single plan will treat your request.

Federal review: A 2022 HHS Office of Inspector General report sampled denials from 15 large Medicare Advantage companies and found that 13% of prior authorization denials met Medicare coverage rules and likely would have been approved under Original Medicare.

The lesson is not to avoid every plan with prior authorization, but to appeal when a denial seems wrong. Read more in our guide on whether Medicare Advantage plans require prior authorization.

Red Flag 4: Plans Ending for 2027

A plan that is leaving your county is the worst plan to sit still in. Several insurers trimmed their 2027 lineups. News coverage reports Humana expected about 600,000 members to be affected by its 2027 exits, Providence Health Plan is winding down coverage for more than 64,000 Medicare Advantage members, and Presbyterian Health Plan is ending most of its plans.

1

Read the non-renewal letter Plans that are ending had to mail notices in early October. The letter names your last day of coverage, usually December 31, 2026.

2

Pick a new plan by December 7 Choosing during the Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, 2026, avoids any gap on January 1.

3

Know your extra window If you miss that date, a non-renewal generally gives you a special enrollment period that runs into early 2027.

4

Consider Original Medicare Losing a plan this way can also give you a guaranteed right to buy certain Medigap policies, depending on the timing.

Compare plans and enroll online

How to Check Any Plan Yourself in 15 Minutes

1

Find the plan on Medicare Plan Finder Enter your ZIP code and medications so costs reflect your situation.

2

Look at the overall star rating Check for the low performer icon and open the detailed measures on care and member experience.

3

Check every doctor and your hospital Use the plan’s 2027 directory, then confirm with each office.

4

Compare the yearly out-of-pocket maximum A $0 premium plan can carry a high maximum. The national average 2027 premium is $12.00 a month.

5

Review drug coverage Look at tiers, prior authorization and step therapy flags on your medications. Part D costs are capped at $2,400 for 2027.

6

Read the Evidence of Coverage Search it for the services you use most to see which need approval.

Signs of a weak fit

✔

2.5 stars or lower, or a low performer icon

✔

Key doctors out of network

✔

High maximum with copays you will hit

✔

Your drugs on high tiers or restricted

Signs of a solid fit

✔

3.5 stars or higher with stable history

✔

Doctors and hospital confirmed for 2027

✔

Out-of-pocket limit you can afford

✔

Drugs covered at a predictable cost

What to Do If You Are Already in a Weak Plan

You have more than one chance to fix a poor choice. During the Annual Enrollment Period you can switch to any plan in your area. From January 1 to March 31, 2027, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period lets you make one change to another Medicare Advantage plan or go back to Original Medicare.

Options to keep in mind

✔

Switch plans during the Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, 2026

✔

Use the January 1 to March 31, 2027 window for one more change

✔

Ask Medicare about the low performer special enrollment period if your plan has the icon

✔

File an appeal or grievance if care is denied, and keep copies of every notice

Our step-by-step guide on how to switch Medicare Advantage plans for 2027 covers timing and what happens to your old plan.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

The worst Medicare Advantage plan is the one that fails you specifically: low or chronically poor star ratings, a network without your doctors, or rules that block the care and drugs you need. Check the exact plan in your county against these objective signals, and remember that ending plans and low performer flags give you extra chances to move.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Which Medicare Advantage company is the worst?

No company is the worst everywhere. CMS rates each contract separately, so the same insurer can have strong and weak plans in different states. Judge the specific plan offered in your ZIP code.

➤ What does the low performer icon mean?

It means a plan’s overall star rating has been below 3 stars for at least three years in a row. Members of these plans may get a one-time chance, processed by Medicare, to move to a plan rated 3 stars or higher.

➤ How many Medicare Advantage contracts scored poorly for 2027?

Coverage of the October 2026 CMS release reports 32 contracts at 2.5 stars or fewer, up from 23 the prior year. The lowest score given was 2 stars.

➤ Is a 3-star Medicare Advantage plan bad?

A 3-star plan is about average, not automatically bad. Look at the measure-level scores to see where it falls short, and compare it with higher-rated plans that cover your doctors.

➤ Do some insurers deny more prior authorization requests?

Yes. KFF found 2024 denial rates ranged from 4.2% at Elevance Health to 12.8% at UnitedHealth Group. Company-wide rates do not predict how a single request will go, so appeal if a denial seems wrong.

➤ Are appeals worth filing?

Usually, yes. KFF found that about 81% of appealed prior authorization denials in 2024 were overturned, but only about 1 in 9 denials was appealed.

➤ What happens if my plan is ending in 2027?

Your coverage typically ends December 31, 2026. Pick a new plan by December 7 to avoid a gap, or use the special enrollment period that a non-renewal usually triggers.

➤ Can I leave a bad plan after January 1?

Yes. The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31, 2027 lets you make one switch to another Medicare Advantage plan or return to Original Medicare.

Advertisement

Medicare Advantage Plan Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company