Worst Medicare Supplement Companies: Top 10 Red Flags to Check Before You Buy

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 18, 2026

The worst Medicare Supplement companies for you are the ones with a weak financial strength rating, a complaint index well above 1.00, a pattern of steep yearly rate hikes, or a plan block that is closed to new buyers. Because every Plan G or Plan N pays the same benefits no matter who sells it, the insurer’s stability, pricing behavior and service record are the only real differences, and all of them can be checked with public data.

2027 by the Numbers

1.00

national average on the NAIC complaint index (share of complaints vs. share of premium)

~44,000

Medicare Supplement members affected when Allstate Health Solutions announced its Medigap exit in May 2025 (agency report)

51 / 0.83

complaints and index for Anthem Insurance Companies in Indiana’s 2025 health complaint index (Indiana DOI)

People search for a list of bad Medigap insurers hoping someone has already done the homework. The problem is that a carrier can be a poor fit in one state and a strong value in the next, and a rate spike in one ZIP code says little about another. A ranking that just names brands tends to be out of date the week it is published.

A better approach is to know the warning signs and look them up yourself. This guide walks through ten red flags, shows what real state complaint data looks like, and explains what to do if your current insurer starts showing them. If you want the positive side of the same research, see our page on best rated Medicare Supplement plans.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Benefits are standardized, so the company is what you are really choosing

✔

A complaint index above 1.00 means more complaints than the insurer’s size predicts

✔

Small insurers can post huge index numbers from a single complaint

✔

A carrier that stops selling new policies can leave an aging, shrinking pool behind

Compare plans and enroll online

Why the Company Matters When the Benefits Are Identical

Federal law locks down what each lettered plan pays. A Plan G from a household name and a Plan G from a small regional insurer cover the same hospital, doctor and skilled nursing costs. So the label on the card does not change a single claim. What it changes is how much you pay over 10 or 20 years, how smoothly claims and billing run, and how safe your coverage is if the company hits hard times.

That is why the phrase worst company is really shorthand for three risks: pricing risk, service risk and financial risk. Each has a public data source. None of them requires trusting a sales pitch, including ours.

Pricing risk

Large or frequent rate increases after year one

Service risk

Complaints about claims, billing and delays

Financial risk

Weak ratings or a shrinking book of business

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

The 10 Red Flags, Ranked by How Much They Can Cost You

1

1. Plan closed to new buyers When an insurer stops selling a plan, healthy new members stop joining. The remaining group gets older and files more claims, which can push premiums up.

2

2. Exit from the Medigap market Existing policies stay in force, but the company has no reason to compete for your loyalty and may not offer a newer plan if you want to change.

3

3. Repeated double-digit rate increases One large increase can happen anywhere. A string of them in the same state is a pattern worth noting.

4

4. Teaser pricing A first-year rate far below every competitor can mean the insurer plans to make it up later.

5

5. Financial strength rating below A- AM Best grades insurers on their ability to pay claims. Below A- is a reason to ask questions.

6

6. Complaint index well above 1.00 Check your own state’s numbers, not a national headline.

7

7. Slow or confusing claims handling Medigap claims are usually automatic through Medicare crossover. Frequent billing problems are a warning sign.

8

8. Discounts that disappear A household discount that shrinks after year one changes the real price.

9

9. Pressure to drop current coverage A replacement only makes sense if it saves money or fits better, and you may face health questions to get it.

10

10. No clear answer on who issues the policy You should always be able to name the legal company on your contract and look it up.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Reading a Complaint Index Without Getting Fooled

The complaint index compares an insurer’s share of complaints with its share of premium in a state. A score of 1.00 is average. A score of 2.00 means twice the complaints you would expect for that company’s size. A score of 0.50 means half.

The catch is sample size. In Indiana’s 2025 health complaint index, one insurer with about $1.3 million in Indiana health premium recorded a single complaint and still posted an index near 39. At the same time, Anthem Insurance Companies logged 51 complaints on more than $3.1 billion in premium and scored 0.83. The bigger company had far more complaints and the better score, because the index is about proportion, not volume.

Insurer (as listed by Indiana DOI) Complaints Indiana premium Index
Anthem Ins Co Inc 51 $3.15 billion 0.83
UnitedHealthcare Ins Co 31 $1.04 billion 1.52
Cigna Hlth & Life Ins Co 2 $265 million 0.39
Humana Ins Co 3 $165 million 0.93
National Hlth Ins Co 1 $45 million 1.13
Small insurer example 1 $1.3 million 39.47

Source: Indiana Department of Insurance, 2025 Health Complaint Index. Figures cover all health lines the insurer reports in Indiana, not only Medicare Supplement, and the report says Medicare and Medicaid premium is excluded. Use it as a starting point, not a verdict.

Check what the index counts: Some state reports bundle every health product together or leave certain Medicare business out. Before you judge a Medigap insurer by its score, read the notes at the top of the report to see what premium was included.

When a Carrier Stops Selling Medigap: The Allstate Example

Market exits are the clearest, most verifiable red flag. In May 2025, Allstate Health Solutions, the former National General health brand, told agents it would file notices to leave the Medicare Supplement market state by state. Agency reports put the number of affected members at roughly 44,000. The company said existing policyholders would keep their coverage and service as long as premiums are paid.

That is the legal minimum, because Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable. But a block of business with no new members tends to age, and older pools usually cost more to insure. Members in that position are not forced to move, yet many choose to shop before rate increases pile up. Our guide to switching Medicare Supplement plans covers the steps.

Stay with an exiting carrier

✔

No new health questions

✔

Same benefits keep paying

✔

Premiums may climb as the pool ages

✔

Fewer options to change plans in-house

Move to an active carrier

✔

Join a pool still adding members

✔

Usually requires passing underwriting

✔

Overlap coverage until the new policy starts

✔

Compare total cost, not just year one

How to Check Any Medicare Supplement Company in 20 Minutes

1

Find the legal company name The brand on the ad is often a parent. The contract names the insurer that actually owes you claims.

2

Look up the AM Best rating AM Best publishes financial strength ratings for each insurer. A++ and A+ are Superior, A and A- are Excellent.

3

Pull your state’s complaint data Many state insurance departments post a yearly complaint index or complaint counts by company.

4

Ask for rate history An agent can usually show past increases for your plan letter in your state. Insurers file rates with the state, and some states post them.

5

Confirm the plan is still open Ask directly whether the company is still selling that plan to new applicants in your state.

Good signs to look for

✔

Rated A- or better by AM Best for the issuing company

✔

Complaint index near or below 1.00 in your state, with enough premium to be meaningful

✔

Steady, moderate rate changes rather than big swings

✔

Actively selling the plan letter you want

Compare plans and enroll online

Rate Increases: Separating Normal From Alarming

Every Medigap premium rises over time. Medical costs go up, and in many states the rating method itself adds increases as you age. Our page on how Medigap premiums are calculated explains attained-age, issue-age and community pricing.

What separates a fair company from a costly one is the size and pattern of increases after you join. We do not publish a list of increase percentages by carrier here, because filed rates differ by state, plan and age band, and any single number would mislead most readers. Ask for your own state’s history instead.

Medicare Part B is rising too: The 2026 Part B premium is $202.90 with a $283 deductible. CMS set $209.40 and $292 for 2027. Plan G does not pay the Part B deductible, so that increase lands on you no matter which insurer you pick.

What to Do If Your Insurer Shows Several Red Flags

Seeing one warning sign is not a reason to panic. Seeing three or four at once is a reason to compare. In most states you will need to answer health questions to move to a new insurer outside your first six months on Part B, so check your options while you are healthy.

Before you switch

✔

Get quotes for the same plan letter so you compare price, not benefits

✔

Check whether your state has a birthday rule or other yearly switching right

✔

Do not cancel your current policy until the new one is approved and active

✔

Ask whether you qualify for any guaranteed issue right; see our page on guaranteed issue rights

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

There is no permanent list of the worst Medicare Supplement companies, because ratings, complaint records and pricing change by year and by state. Check the issuing company’s AM Best rating, your state’s complaint data, its rate history and whether it still sells the plan. A company that fails several of those checks is one to avoid or leave while you can still pass underwriting.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Which Medicare Supplement company has the most complaints?

That depends on the state and the year, and raw complaint counts mostly reflect size. A better measure is the complaint index, which adjusts for how much premium the insurer collects in that state.

➤ Is a complaint index of 2.0 bad?

It means the insurer drew about twice the complaints its size would predict. For a large insurer with plenty of premium, that is worth noting. For a tiny insurer, one or two complaints can push the number that high.

➤ Did Allstate stop selling Medicare Supplement plans?

Allstate Health Solutions announced in May 2025 that it would exit the Medicare Supplement market, filing notices state by state. It said current policyholders would keep their coverage as long as premiums are paid.

➤ Can a Medigap insurer cancel my policy because of my health?

No. Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable, so the insurer cannot cancel you for health reasons while you pay your premium and answered the application honestly.

➤ What AM Best rating should a Medigap company have?

Many shoppers look for A- (Excellent) or better on the company that actually issues the policy. Ratings can change, so check the current grade on AM Best before you apply.

➤ Why would cheap Medigap premiums be a red flag?

A first-year price far below the market can be followed by larger increases later. Compare the company’s past rate changes in your state, not just the opening quote.

➤ Does a closed block of business affect my premium?

It can. When no new members join a plan, the group ages and claims rise, which may lead to higher premiums for those who stay.

➤ Where can I find complaint data for my state?

Your state insurance department is the best source. Many post a yearly complaint index or complaint counts by company, and the NAIC also offers consumer complaint lookups.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-877-436-2343

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-877-436-2343TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET